As technology advances, it is increasingly intertwined with every aspect of our society, including copyright law. The rise of artificial intelligence (AI) has raised a number of fundamental questions and challenges for copyright law, as Generative AI systems are now capable of producing text, images, video, and audio that would traditionally be protected by copyright if created by a human.
Who Owns the Rights to AI-Generated Material?
The convergence of AI and copyright has opened a Pandora’s box of questions, the most pressing being: Who truly owns the rights to AI-generated material? Existing copyright law awards protection to “original works of authorship.” But can content generated by an algorithm be deemed “original”?
Some say AI outputs lack originality since they are generated by machines, not humans. Others contend that if AI outputs reflect a distinct “creative essence” beyond mere replication of existing content, they should qualify.
This debate intensifies with AI’s expanding role in collaborative ventures. Consider an AI system suggesting plot points for a story, which a human writer then elaborates upon. Who, in this tandem, wears the “author” badge?
This ambiguity has real-world implications. A surge of applications at the United States Copyright Office (USCO) seeks registration for works with AI as a co-author. In contrast, copyright owners are sounding alarms about potential infringements tied to AI’s training on copyrighted content. The future of copyright in the AI era will depend on how we define creativity and authorship.
Navigating the New Landscape
Recognizing the depth and breadth of these concerns, the USCO has launched a comprehensive initiative to investigate these pressing issues. As part of this endeavor, the Office has released a paper and is soliciting feedback. The USCO has outlined a framework for understanding the different issues raised by AI and copyright. This structured approach promises to be an indispensable guide for policymakers, businesses, and creators as they adapt to this evolving landscape:
- The necessity for protections against AI mimicking human artistry.
- How current legislation, such as the Copyright Act and state right of publicity laws, engages with AI.
- The intricacies of AI training in relation to copyright and the consequent economic impacts.
- The technical challenges faced, including AI output identification and the use of metadata.
- Potential legal recourses, liabilities, and the very definition of copyrightability in AI outputs.
Be a Part of the Movement
But this initiative isn’t just for policy-makers or tech gurus. The rapid growth and omnipresence of AI mean that its implications touch everyone. From artists, writers, and musicians to tech developers, educators, and everyday consumers, everyone has a stake in this evolving narrative.
The USCO seeks your invaluable insights, concerns, and opinions on these matters. If you have insights, concerns, or opinions on the intersection of AI and copyright, please share them with the USCO. In addition, the World Intellectual Patent Office (WIPO) is holding FREE webinars to explore the intersection of Generative AI and IP (September 20 and 21)
Your voice matters. Make it heard. As AI and copyright chart their future course, let’s ensure it’s one that not only respects the sanctity of original creation but also embraces the transformative potential of technology.
If you enjoyed this post please support our work by encouraging your friends and colleagues to subscribe to our newsletter: